This post may seem to be a departure from the more mundane topics I am used to tackling, but the recent Sen-Bhagwati debates, as acerbic as they have become, did more than just catch my eye. On the one hand we have the Nobel Laureate, the doyen of poverty economics; the other side is represented by an equally brilliant, and proficient, advocate of globalization. It was, and still is, a battle made in hell, seemingly, where neither side is willing to give a quarter, nor ask for one.
A feature of economics, like many sciences, is the habit economists have of making mistakes, and then learning from them. The bigger problem, sadly, is that economic mistakes, again like mistakes of some sciences, are so catastrophic in nature that there is only the din of a disaster which looms in the air. Even if someone does learn from such a mistake, it is already too late to save the guinea pig, which in the case of economic experiments, is the poor, unsuspecting, less "intellectual" public, which has no clue about economics, except notional ones.
In a nutshell, the essence of the so-called disagreements (a mild word, if I might add) between the two intellectuals lies in the difference over how to achieve betterment of the country at large. To a layman, either way sounds reasonable; India is a land of poverty, so the poor need support, a stand having Sen's endorsement; conversely, India lags in terms of overall growth, so it needs to grow, which should pull the prosperity level of people as a result, a stand having Bhagwati's approval.
Another great dichotomy which exists in economics is the presence of multiple solutions- perfectly reasonable, and totally opposite- to the same problem. "That is a good thing", many would say; "if a problem can be solved in more than one way, what is the harm in it?", would be another retort. And yes, even I agree with that in principle. The dichotomy becomes an anomaly when applied to a real world example, because a real world has context; and when it comes to today's India, the anomaly can become downright chaos and disaster.
It is not an unfamiliar territory which India finds herself in currently; burgeoning fiscal deficits, high inflation, a weakening currency, flight of money etc.....a situation a la 1991 might indeed be nigh. And as has been the case throughout independent India's history, at the crux lies economic mismanagement, even for this disaster which looms like a haunting shadow upon India. It might be attributed to poorly executed social welfare scheme(s), which the current government claims as the greatest contribution by it to this country and her citizens.
That the current government has socialist leanings is an open secret. Hence the government's thrust on the current ordinance pertaining to food security should come as no surprise. But should the government carelessly and brazenly overlook the Opposition, ineffectual even though it might be, just to win a few brownie points, even considering the fact that elections are around the corner? Is retaining power, even at the cost of depleting the sovereign coffers, so vital?
It is with this background that Mr Sen attempts to endorse the government's harebrained schemes, not without certain scruples, though. His focus on the poorer sections is totally understandable and commendable. But if he claims to be an economist of any standing, he should also stick to his brief, and understand the fiscal implications of the schemes which he backs in principle, even if not in toto. His ideal of poverty eradication is laudable, but doing so at a cost that the entire country might have to pay is totally unacceptable.
And that is the pitfall if an intellectual starts making such grave mistakes; being highly intelligent, the mistakes of such people are magnified several times, and the after-effects are just, well, gruesome. I can only speak as much as I know, or perceive, and that is the said ordinance, though noble in essence, is an exercise in meaningless extravagance and utter stupidity (in truth, nobility and stupidity often go hand in hand), considering that the pinch of inflation affects the middle class more than the modern aristocracy which is the ruling coalition.
Bhagwati, on the other hand, though making crucial interventions academically, is doing it in a very puerile manner. It is one thing to disagree with someone, happens all the time all over the world; it is entirely another thing to excoriate someone just to make a point contrary to the person we subject to said treatment. And Bhagwati's piece where he dissects and deconstructs Sen's logic defies logic. If an intellectual has to resort to such methods to disagree, no wonder we are getting the politicians we deserve. No doubt the article was strong, but the tone could have been subtler. After all, no one is subtler than an economist, I believe. As for "The Argumentative Indian", he should be ready to argue with those who dare disagree with him; the very unwillingness to do that smacks of hypocrisy.
It really is the ultimate irony; two learned individuals slinging more than mud at each other, when they could and should be helping the government with their wisdom. But then again, when there such chasms of opinion, unanimity is the toughest thing to achieve, in spite of all the knowledge people may possess. And India is the worse for it. Again.
A feature of economics, like many sciences, is the habit economists have of making mistakes, and then learning from them. The bigger problem, sadly, is that economic mistakes, again like mistakes of some sciences, are so catastrophic in nature that there is only the din of a disaster which looms in the air. Even if someone does learn from such a mistake, it is already too late to save the guinea pig, which in the case of economic experiments, is the poor, unsuspecting, less "intellectual" public, which has no clue about economics, except notional ones.
In a nutshell, the essence of the so-called disagreements (a mild word, if I might add) between the two intellectuals lies in the difference over how to achieve betterment of the country at large. To a layman, either way sounds reasonable; India is a land of poverty, so the poor need support, a stand having Sen's endorsement; conversely, India lags in terms of overall growth, so it needs to grow, which should pull the prosperity level of people as a result, a stand having Bhagwati's approval.
Another great dichotomy which exists in economics is the presence of multiple solutions- perfectly reasonable, and totally opposite- to the same problem. "That is a good thing", many would say; "if a problem can be solved in more than one way, what is the harm in it?", would be another retort. And yes, even I agree with that in principle. The dichotomy becomes an anomaly when applied to a real world example, because a real world has context; and when it comes to today's India, the anomaly can become downright chaos and disaster.
It is not an unfamiliar territory which India finds herself in currently; burgeoning fiscal deficits, high inflation, a weakening currency, flight of money etc.....a situation a la 1991 might indeed be nigh. And as has been the case throughout independent India's history, at the crux lies economic mismanagement, even for this disaster which looms like a haunting shadow upon India. It might be attributed to poorly executed social welfare scheme(s), which the current government claims as the greatest contribution by it to this country and her citizens.
That the current government has socialist leanings is an open secret. Hence the government's thrust on the current ordinance pertaining to food security should come as no surprise. But should the government carelessly and brazenly overlook the Opposition, ineffectual even though it might be, just to win a few brownie points, even considering the fact that elections are around the corner? Is retaining power, even at the cost of depleting the sovereign coffers, so vital?
It is with this background that Mr Sen attempts to endorse the government's harebrained schemes, not without certain scruples, though. His focus on the poorer sections is totally understandable and commendable. But if he claims to be an economist of any standing, he should also stick to his brief, and understand the fiscal implications of the schemes which he backs in principle, even if not in toto. His ideal of poverty eradication is laudable, but doing so at a cost that the entire country might have to pay is totally unacceptable.
And that is the pitfall if an intellectual starts making such grave mistakes; being highly intelligent, the mistakes of such people are magnified several times, and the after-effects are just, well, gruesome. I can only speak as much as I know, or perceive, and that is the said ordinance, though noble in essence, is an exercise in meaningless extravagance and utter stupidity (in truth, nobility and stupidity often go hand in hand), considering that the pinch of inflation affects the middle class more than the modern aristocracy which is the ruling coalition.
Bhagwati, on the other hand, though making crucial interventions academically, is doing it in a very puerile manner. It is one thing to disagree with someone, happens all the time all over the world; it is entirely another thing to excoriate someone just to make a point contrary to the person we subject to said treatment. And Bhagwati's piece where he dissects and deconstructs Sen's logic defies logic. If an intellectual has to resort to such methods to disagree, no wonder we are getting the politicians we deserve. No doubt the article was strong, but the tone could have been subtler. After all, no one is subtler than an economist, I believe. As for "The Argumentative Indian", he should be ready to argue with those who dare disagree with him; the very unwillingness to do that smacks of hypocrisy.
It really is the ultimate irony; two learned individuals slinging more than mud at each other, when they could and should be helping the government with their wisdom. But then again, when there such chasms of opinion, unanimity is the toughest thing to achieve, in spite of all the knowledge people may possess. And India is the worse for it. Again.