Monday, 20 May 2019

Communism


Any group which requires its members to accept its tenets without question should expect a lot of criticism from the intellectual class as well as the ruling class. That is what any person operating on logic would also do. One of the most common ideologies which faces this problem, and rightfully so, is organized religion, particularly the Abrahamic faiths.

The notion that only one book can contain the answers to all the questions humanity poses is ridiculous, and frankly it also reeks of smugness and arrogance. That is the first source of trouble. The trouble is magnified when multiple books are created which challenge and contradict each other as to what is correct.

The problem with Abrahamic faiths is their assumption, and subsequent emphasis, that the words contained in their respective books are the words of God.  It is this reason why there was a spate of secularist movements in the Western world, which led to the concept of the separation of the Church from the State. With all its condescension towards the so called Third World countries about religious freedom and other nonsense, the West has been remarkably hypocritical in the past and even today on this issue. This is why these faiths, while having found sanctuary in India, are struggling to find new recruits, another reason why the Catholic Church is pushing the envelope so that it can harvest more souls from India. With the doors to China being firmly shut in their faces, the Abrahamic faiths, and Christianity and Islam in particular, are keen on targeting India with ridiculous reports about a sudden decrease in religious freedom.

Many people do not like him, but to suggest that Narendra Modi is the most dangerous person in the country, who may cause damage the likes of which hasn’t been seen before, is quite a tall leap of imagination even from the “intellectuals” of our country. And to suggest that in Modi’s India, the minorities are facing an existential threat is an insult to the continuous history of this ancient land. Of all countries in the world, India has been shelter to people of all hues, creeds and ethnic persuasion. And India, throughout her history, has faced invaders and foreign conquerors who make Mr. Modi look like God. Our so called intellectuals really have selective amnesia. But it is all very understandable.

You see, when it comes to groups, there is one group which, in its relatively short existence on this planet, has had a death toll which will put all the religious wars to shame. This group has ushered in death, destruction, famine and mass murders on a scale hitherto unseen, which really makes one wonder as to the depths to which humans can sink. They are the COMMUNISTS, and any amount of vitriol for these creatures is not enough.

The scourge of communism is so all-pervading that India is still struggling to shake it off. Amongst the many blunders of Mr. Nehru, the second biggest was to develop India along the central planning route. So, what is the big deal, one might wonder. The problem developed into a bubble which left us red-faced in that magnificent summer of 1991, when we had to default on our loans to various external lenders. As if this was not bad enough, the Communist intelligentsia shoved the notion that this slow pace of economic development was the “Hindu rate of growth” down our throats. Can you imagine the gall of these “intellectuals”? Hiding their crimes and using flowery language to confuse the commoners, whom they claim to represent, is child’s play for these people.

It is not just in India where communists have spread their tentacles. Russia, that gigantic landmass, was the first to bear the brunt of these thugs. Soon, the whole of Eastern Europe, Central Asia and Latin America were swept up in their wake. And then, China, the most populous country, fell to the Red scourge under Mao. What followed next was a human tragedy.

An oft repeated adage is, “those who forget history are condemned to repeat it”. It is unbelievable, then, that when it comes to Communism, people make the same mistakes. Why is that the case? Lack of education is one major factor. In India, for the longest time possible, the school curricula were in accordance with what the Left thought should be taught. This would of course gloss over the many crimes committed by their brethren in India and other countries. It is only in the last few years with the spread of the internet that people are seeing the real, ugly side of this ideology. Secondly, there is a fear of retribution which may cause people to refrain from speaking against Communist monstrosities. After all, Communism and its stooges are no strangers to violence: it is their stated goal to bring about violent revolution in places where Communism is not present in full strength. Thirdly, as mentioned before, Communism has a way with words and rhetoric, which is enough to lull the most gullible into supporting them. Their shrill cries of idealism have no basis in the ground realities, and the youth of the country are most vulnerable to this, and it is indeed an alarming sign that many youths are getting seduced by this fiendish ideology.

Violence is the go-to option for Communists, and their indefatigability is something to be admired. In India, the Maoists are the armed wing of the Communists, who repeatedly carry out attacks on paramilitary forces in affected areas. I have not seen any Communist condemning such attacks. Why? Are human rights only for their loved ones, and not for everyone?

As also touched upon previously, hypocrisy is ingrained in Communists to the extent that it is shocking none in the mainstream media have highlighted it. That is because the MSM is also afflicted by the Communist virus. In India, the infiltration of Communism into almost all the pillars of democracy has been so prolonged that even today, the press continues with its egregious and selective reporting, which reeks of bias from a mile off. Of course, the presence of alternative sources of media has curbed this to an extent, but the rot remains. 

Another reason why Communists damage a nation permanently is their abhorrence of individual excellence. This is a major reason why India slumped to such low rates of growth. A quest for excellence from an individual was sacrificed for the society’s progress, which also did not occur as desired. Consequently, industrial growth petered out, and corruption boomed. It is this corruption which has been shut out to some extent during this government, after its zenith under the previous one.

Another excess of Communism was the birth of the cult of personality, which in India began with Mr. Nehru, and then reached its peak under Ms. Indira Gandhi. That centralization of power has continued to this day with the Congress Party, which has been influenced by leftist ideals ever since Independence.

The other reason why Abrahamic faiths, and Communism for that matter, have not been able to dent the Indian public life is because their origins lie outside India. It’s not for a lack of trying, though: even now, the Church is hell bent on bringing India to her knees, and all the demonstrations that we have seen against industries and development projects will have either the Church or the Communists as the troublemakers. Be it the Sardar Sarovar Dam, the Kudankulam Plant, the Sterlite agitation, one can find their ominous presence.

While they consider themselves to be atheists, their obsession with siding with other religions at the expense of Sanatana Dharma is what really makes me speechless. Indeed, it is this contempt of theirs for a philosophy, which is beyond the comprehension of their minds, which brings out the innate hypocrite present in every Communist. Maybe it is their desperation at not being able to convince the whole population about the supposed merits of their ideology which causes them to take such a direct route.

You must have noticed that one cannot say which is the worst thing perpetrated by this ideology. Their crimes are such that one will recoil in horror at the impunity with which they have been carrying them out, virtually undetected for the longest time. I recall with horror when I first saw on TV the excesses of the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia, with the graves of skulls and what not pockmarking a country with a glorious history. Over time, I came to realize that it was not even the tip of the iceberg, when we put those crimes alongside what happened in Russia and China. And this has been the story across the world, where great civilizations and economies were destroyed by the menace of these thugs.

Can these Communists be thwarted? They can be, but they will still be present in the form of scars, much like the cancer cells which are often not fully destroyed. That is what Communists are akin to: cancer. It is for the people to realize that they are not what they profess to do or be, and are hypocrites of the worst kind, a behaviour which needs to be called out every time. Only then can we really expect a more inclusive growth across the country.

Sunday, 18 December 2016

Reflections

It's not everyday that one enters a new decade of his/her life. It is a momentous occasion which entails shouldering of newer and more challenging responsibilities. However, it is also a time for earnest reflections.

To be fair, during a period of ten years there would be periods of gaiety, sandwiched between moments of despair and touched by instances of the sublime and the ridiculous. For me the decade gone by began while I was a student, who had no idea about who he was, with very bleak prospects for the future due to punishments meted out for a misdemeanor I was part of.

The unsure student would slowly gain confidence and choose a tougher job, and soon it gave him an intensity which has not deserted him since. Along the way, he would also flirt with the idea of celibacy, which would also not desert him going ahead.

The rough professional gave way to the student, again, albeit a quieter and apparently arrogant one. The two years spent therein were challenging and rewarding in equal measure, and for good measure the way to becoming a corporate slave was paved with no fuss at all.

This period, however, saw the celibate designate being challenged by  some beautiful sights, all of which were magnetic enough to quash the remnants of the celibate dream. One in particular has stayed with him to this day, something which makes him happy and torments him no end. Talk about contradictions!

The slavery has continued till date, where a thirst for knowledge rubs shoulders with the more forceful external stimulus of bending over. The only moderating influences have been the presence of sane colleagues and the tendency to keep the grey cells occupied through reading and writing.

While summarizing anything is very dangerous and avoidable, it has to be said that as of now, things are in a state of suspended animation insofar as my existence is concerned. But maybe it's not such a bad thing after all, because  I am sure things could be worse, have been worse, and will in fact only get better.

Obviously, if anything there exist deadly contradictions inside me, but I can defend that with the simple explanation of having seen the best and the worst of something(s). And if that does not satisfy the obstinate creature who may be inferring something nasty about me, there is the best thing one can declare about me, namely that I am mad. After all, it takes a special kind of lunacy to dream of union and celibacy at the same time!

For an impulse decision to write about this, the piece has stretched too long. And if you have stuck till the end reading all this, I really cannot thank  you enough and think how idiotic you are ;), but a good thing you did, really! 

Tuesday, 6 December 2016

The indomitable woman

First of all, this is neither a glowing tribute, nor is it a scathing critique. This is just an observation of a woman who was called something she never became. And even that is irrelevant in the bigger scheme.


It is not often that one sees a funeral of a person attended by so many heads of governments. But then again, it is not the funeral everyday of someone like Jayalalitha.

Subjected to the telecast on all channels of the last journey, it really was evident that this was no ordinary person, though I already knew it. A woman who made a government at the Centre fall by one vote, a woman who was almost disrobed in her own State Assembly, a woman who defied all exit polls by retaining power in the most notoriously predictable of states....talk about fighting tough odds!

True, she was not perfect, but then no one is. What is more to the point is the will the woman had. There were several charges of corruption over the years, several humiliations both electorally and sartorially, but through it all she never seemed to lose her equanimity.

It is equally relevant to note that she was known to be a great administrator, a trait which has been lacking in our country across regimes for years beyond count. In a ruthless field, she added a new streak almost imperceptibly. Add to that a mean streak and one can understand how dangerous she was for her rivals. Just remember her night time arrests of her political rivals...

Our country has had some extraordinary woman leaders. I don't know whether it is in the genes or just the circumstances, but many of them have been ruthless when in power. Women of today, take note!

As she now rests six feet under the earth, all the experts have started analyzing her impact and the void her departure has created. It has no parallel, to be fair. Not many become icons while they live, and even fewer become Gods. For all her flaws, and  there were many, we could do with more leaders like her, who just do their work and not propagandize.

An enigma, an actress, an administrator par excellence, and certainly an articulate politician and interviewee, she was so much rolled into one. Add to that a resilient fighter and one got what the world would remember as J Jayalalitha!

Saturday, 30 January 2016

Discussions on the Greatest(s) in Sports

Surely this has to be the topic which brings out all sorts of passions inside us. Irrespective of barriers. The levels of vehemence which are attained during such a discussion are just unbelievable. I guess that is the beauty about sports. There is a raw side to it, which espouses and invokes such deep emotions that we are caught in them.

While a similar debate can, and indeed does, happen for other professions as well, sports is a different ball game altogether. We can connect to it, and indeed we live vicariously through the legends and the greats who achieve such feats in their various arenas and stadia. This led to a (not too) narrow stream, namely of sports.

Time and again, each sport brings forth individuals (and teams) who literally transcend hitherto existing levels of excellence. Brazil 1970, Lin Dan, Usain Bolt et al are just a few examples off the top of my head. Each of these can claim the tag of the greatest. But what makes them so? Is it only numbers which can define that status?

Numbers are obviously the best point to start any such discussion. I guess that is the beauty of numbers in general, and statistics in particular. They certainly separate the best from the rest. After all, the also ran will not have numbers comparable to a winner, in an overwhelming majority of the cases. They tell a good portion of the story associated with each sports entity. Only a good portion, however. If only numbers were to be the deciding factor, there would be no debate at all. So it can be agreed that numbers alone are not enough.

To aid the numbers, it is important to note as to how those numbers were achieved, which is basically the setting in which the performances occurred, and the impact of the athlete (team).

So simple, isn't it?

Part of the reason why there is rarely any unanimity in such discussions is that there is no measurement for impact (statistically there may be, and that is a downside for me). Impact here may be on both the sport and the individual stating the case for a particular entity. And that, more than anything else, is the beauty of such debates. I may have been impacted by one player more than any other, and there is no way that can be broken down into numbers.

Time brings about many changes in the world. Sports is also affected. Rules change, and so do the conditions. Since the discussion is for the greatest of all time, it will come to a stage where there will be a comparison of entities from entirely different eras, arguably the most difficult thing to do. And in such debates, this also marks the point of no return. Ultimately, it becomes a comparison of the impacts of the respective entities which, as pointed out, will always remain subjective.

Impact takes on another dimension, when the debate is about the greatest player in a team sport (football, cricket). It is the impact of the player on the team. So, it's another subjective parameter, and is of no help whatsoever in arriving at an objective decision. But then again, such debates are for entertainment, not for arriving at a decision. Had the latter been the case, our ingenious human minds would have come up with a complicated formula to reach a decision.

Long live the debate, and may it forever be healthy and furious!


Wednesday, 12 August 2015

Mr Murphy's Thoughts

We are all aware of what Murphy's Law is all about. It has been used widely in more jocular settings, sometimes even serious ones. While it's all great to use it left right and center, I wondered what the man whose name is attached to the law would think about the usage of the same. What follows is a figment of my- rather, Mr. Murphy's-imagination.

"I never thought my name will forever be linked to any disaster of any magnitude. What harm did I do to anyone, ever? Perhaps even I am partly at fault. Why, why did I have to make such a profound statement of doom, that too in the simplest way possible? But is it my fault at all? After all, aren't we human beings wont to missing, ignoring and belittling the simple things that are all around us? Isn't our innate curiosity to see the deeper things the reason for our "advancement"? How was I to blame if people didn't ignore my terse statement, as is their habit?

To be honest, I don't know what the fuss is all about. I feel shocked when people link a lot of disasters to what I said. If only they thought a while before doing that! Is it because of me that things go wrong? I can say with absolute confidence that half the people have nary an idea of what goes on around them, and find it convenient to lay the blame squarely on some stranger named Murphy.

Of course, people will say that having a law named after oneself is a cool way to be immortal. I am aghast at hearing this, because I don't want to be the butt of several jokes and angst of people who don't know squat about me, and even less so for things which go wrong. Would sane people like to have their life and their normalcy ruined by being associated with everything that goes wrong? Show me someone and I will eat my fingers.

I sometimes wonder whether people dig deep to find out why things go wrong. Is it because something that was supposed to work in a particular way didn't, or because some dude named Murphy laid a curse that put paid to all chances of success? I won't be a pain in the ass by blaming all the people. There are those who are diligent and industrious, not to mention kind, enough to go to the bottom of everything that goes wrong and come up with a solution for it. They don't take the easy route, namely that of bashing me. If bashing me brings a solution that will cure their ailments or correct their courses, I won't mind. But I firmly believe that such tactics seldom work, if ever.

Why am I writing all this so suddenly? Well, the angst has been building up inside me, but the dam had to burst some time. I am surprised that my delivery has been very civil, because it certainly wasn't the case when these thoughts were inside me. Every time when some a**hole invoked my name for no fault of mine, I wished to Hell for some stroke of lightning to strike that a**hole down. And to think that no one before me in history didn't think of what I said will be an insult to all the wiser people who have preceded me. Somehow, that truth has come to be linked inexorably to my name.

I have a lot more to say, but I don't want to waste my time. If I could meet all the faceless users of my name, I would not smack them or curse them to oblivion, in spite of what I may have mentioned earlier. I would simply insist on exercising restraint and that very rare commodity, which we call common sense, whenever something goes wrong. I may have said it, but there is no need to raise such a hue and cry about it, just because you can. And, in spite of my earnest pleas, if you still have nothing better to do other than besmirching my noble name, I will sincerely wish that WHATEVER CAN GO WRONG WITH YOU, GOES WRONG.

(Wink of the eye and hideous laughter)"

PS: In spite of everything written, let me just put it plainly that chaos will win simply because it is better organized. :)






Monday, 10 August 2015

The curse of being second

Last week saw the completion of 7 decades of a couple of incidents which shook the world, and exposed it to the visible and clandestine powers of an atomic explosion. Visible, as in the dark majesty of the mushroom cloud; invisible, as in the mutations which have rendered a posterity clueless and resigned over the fate which has been meted out to them.

Somehow, it has come to my notice that the attention which Hiroshima receives every 6th August dwarfs the attention which the other city which suffered a similar attack receives. Nagasaki has, to my mind, become a slightly laggard brother in a grisly race for being pummeled by a foreign power, and that saddens me no end. I must admit, however, that I am not being righteous and writing out of anger; I am simply at a loss to understand why Nagasaki doesn't garner the same sympathy which Hiroshima rightly does.

On a broader scope, it is indeed a fact that people rarely remember the second in a list. All the attention, all the brouhaha and indeed all the reams and bandwidths are reserved for the topper, the numero uno, the king and so on. Granted, the attention is well-deserved, perhaps: after all, barring a few cases like the Hiroshima-Nagasaki duo, people and venues do work hard in reaching the top step of the ladder. But the question to be pondered here is: is the one who has come second not worthy of a sliver of that attention, let alone the praise?

People may argue: why should we praise the second in the line? He LOST, and should be consigned to the realms of ignominy. The first was simply BETTER, others will comment. To the first type, I would simply say: please don't paint the world in simple notions of black and white. As for the "being better" rationale, that is still a more logical explanation, yet even that cannot explain the reason for ignoring the one who came second. Is it not worthy of mention that the runner-up mounted a challenge to the seemingly invincible winner?

Or it might be that in regular events where there has to be a winner and then those who just couldn't get past, the coverage due the runner-up might be more than is usual? I am speaking simply from a theoretical point of view, without any number-crunching, and so my assumptions are more likely to be wide off the mark. Having said that, I do know that many will remember the name of the first man to set foot on the moon, but the second will draw a blank look from the same people.

Even as I think while writing, I guess the chances of remembering the second will be more if the second is momentarily behind the first, or if the competition was in real-time (like a track event in the Olympics). The moment there is a gap between the two instances of the same event (being President of the US, for instance), the one who is second may be more prone to losing his/her thunder. But no, even that is no guarantee. I am pretty sure not many would remember the silver medalists of many events in the Olympics. At least, the recall will not be as strong as what it would be for the gold medalist.

I wonder why this discrepancy exists at all. And no, we cannot use the "limited brain capacity" excuse for this. If we can remember the winner, we can just as easily remember the one who just missed out. Has this something to do with our vicarious pleasure in seeing someone win, and seeing our own image in the one who has missed out? After all, our excellent human mind is capable of extraordinary things, and this doesn't seem to be too shocking. Is it a curse to come second in a race, or be the second chronological example of something, never mind how horrible the event might have been? Was it Nagasaki's fault, seemingly, to not be bombed first by the Americans?

If we cannot remember even the horrible seconds, it stands to reason that we don't remember the plight of the athlete who missed out on a gold. If we cannot remember the lives that were lost just because they were the second group to suffer so, how can we spare a moment for the agony of a competitor?

Sunday, 1 December 2013

Fascination with the flawed man

In a very poignant scene in Chak de India, a kid asks his father what a traitor looks like. The father happily obliges, pinpointing the hero who is being forced to vacate an ancestral home for being flawed. The whole crowd is watching.

When it comes to the real world, the situation is more intense, and as expected more tragic. Perhaps it is a human tendency, being interested in picking flaws in other people, and focusing on them. In India, it is nothing short of cult behaviour to be interested in your neighbour's flaws. What is beyond me is, when it comes to some tragic event, why are we so bogged down by the specifics of an individual?

It is a bad thing when someone commits a heinous crime; in such cases, public lacerations and excoriations of the criminals are understandable, maybe even condoned, at least on the social media anyway. However, the key issue is, when the situation arises of an event, which on a majority of occasions goes unnoticed, being fanned far and wide, why do we lose perspective? Why, then, do we focus on the man instead of the circumstances leading up to the crime? Is it a clever ruse to deflect attention from ourselves, with the line, "Look! There is the worst man in this world!"?

I am taking crime only as an example. There can be several events where this discrepancy can be observed. The modes used might be different, the most common of which is pulling someone down from a seemingly higher pedestal he/she might be on. While this might bring a smile on many lips, I also get a feeling of dismay and revulsion. This morbid fascination with the flaws of an individual seems hypocritical, seeing as we all have flaws embedded in our programming.

If no good deed goes unpunished, then why in the event of a bad event is only the man under the spotlight, and not the deed as well? Sure, bringing the man under the microscope does give an insight, but it also happens that such a close examination narrows our perspective, and we lose sight of the bigger picture. Instead of nipping such problems in the bud, we are allowing them to bloom fully, and then paying the price in the distant future. We gravitate to the men who are flawed, either for self-aggrandizing or for vicarious pleasure, and neither is anything to be too proud of.

The Tejpals, Asarams et al are not just exceptions to any grand rule, they are exactly like us; just that they couldn't sate their voracious appetites. But that is no reason to focus on them so keenly; we would do better to focus on the bigger malaise afflicting us, which would be the wise thing.