The title may be looked at with some amount of consternation by the righteous brigade, and for once I would be in agreement with them, if only partially. And therein lies the rub; it is only with a partial sense of consonance that I would stand by their side.
No part of this world has been immune to violence, of whatever kind. Be it armed conflict, uprising, popular struggle, even domestic violence, the world history has been quite a quiet witness to all these occurrences. So, if history shows that violence has been prevalent since the ancient times, why do we cringe at any new instance of this characteristic which defines our world? We should not be so righteous ourselves to be abhorrent to something which we all practice in our daily lives, albeit at varying levels. And indulging in violence, we should not be so condescending to the extent that we stoop extremely low.
As in most cases, the key question is why. Why is violence being perpetrated? Why do we condone it? Do the victims deserve what is being meted out to them? And if they do, why? Then the most obvious answer, again, is, it depends. And that is one reason I partially disagree with those who abhor violence in any form.
Obviously, there are certain clear cases where violence is to be condemned, not condoned. Butchering of hapless victims, a la Hitler, Idi Amin and Milosevic, is strictly taboo, even in my eyes. Beating up one's spouse (read wife) to show purported superiority is another. And yet, there are cases where violence is a necessary evil. Even as staunch an apostle of non-violence as Gandhi admitted, "No one can teach non-violence to a man who cannot kill.". That is an extraordinary statement coming from his lips, which underlines the basic premise I stated of every human being being inherently violent. There are too many examples of famous figures, real and mythological, who espoused violent sentiments, because they felt it would strengthen their kingdoms and empires.
Eventually, it all boils down to what purpose we use violence for, and even then it is for the world at large to decide, though perhaps without reaching a consensus, whether someone used violence for good or evil. Using violence on a marauding army hell bent on destruction is not violence, but a physical catharsis. Simultaneously, using violence to fulfill one's personal agenda is not only violence, but the rape of reason.
No part of this world has been immune to violence, of whatever kind. Be it armed conflict, uprising, popular struggle, even domestic violence, the world history has been quite a quiet witness to all these occurrences. So, if history shows that violence has been prevalent since the ancient times, why do we cringe at any new instance of this characteristic which defines our world? We should not be so righteous ourselves to be abhorrent to something which we all practice in our daily lives, albeit at varying levels. And indulging in violence, we should not be so condescending to the extent that we stoop extremely low.
As in most cases, the key question is why. Why is violence being perpetrated? Why do we condone it? Do the victims deserve what is being meted out to them? And if they do, why? Then the most obvious answer, again, is, it depends. And that is one reason I partially disagree with those who abhor violence in any form.
Obviously, there are certain clear cases where violence is to be condemned, not condoned. Butchering of hapless victims, a la Hitler, Idi Amin and Milosevic, is strictly taboo, even in my eyes. Beating up one's spouse (read wife) to show purported superiority is another. And yet, there are cases where violence is a necessary evil. Even as staunch an apostle of non-violence as Gandhi admitted, "No one can teach non-violence to a man who cannot kill.". That is an extraordinary statement coming from his lips, which underlines the basic premise I stated of every human being being inherently violent. There are too many examples of famous figures, real and mythological, who espoused violent sentiments, because they felt it would strengthen their kingdoms and empires.
Eventually, it all boils down to what purpose we use violence for, and even then it is for the world at large to decide, though perhaps without reaching a consensus, whether someone used violence for good or evil. Using violence on a marauding army hell bent on destruction is not violence, but a physical catharsis. Simultaneously, using violence to fulfill one's personal agenda is not only violence, but the rape of reason.
No comments:
Post a Comment