Sunday, 1 December 2013

Fascination with the flawed man

In a very poignant scene in Chak de India, a kid asks his father what a traitor looks like. The father happily obliges, pinpointing the hero who is being forced to vacate an ancestral home for being flawed. The whole crowd is watching.

When it comes to the real world, the situation is more intense, and as expected more tragic. Perhaps it is a human tendency, being interested in picking flaws in other people, and focusing on them. In India, it is nothing short of cult behaviour to be interested in your neighbour's flaws. What is beyond me is, when it comes to some tragic event, why are we so bogged down by the specifics of an individual?

It is a bad thing when someone commits a heinous crime; in such cases, public lacerations and excoriations of the criminals are understandable, maybe even condoned, at least on the social media anyway. However, the key issue is, when the situation arises of an event, which on a majority of occasions goes unnoticed, being fanned far and wide, why do we lose perspective? Why, then, do we focus on the man instead of the circumstances leading up to the crime? Is it a clever ruse to deflect attention from ourselves, with the line, "Look! There is the worst man in this world!"?

I am taking crime only as an example. There can be several events where this discrepancy can be observed. The modes used might be different, the most common of which is pulling someone down from a seemingly higher pedestal he/she might be on. While this might bring a smile on many lips, I also get a feeling of dismay and revulsion. This morbid fascination with the flaws of an individual seems hypocritical, seeing as we all have flaws embedded in our programming.

If no good deed goes unpunished, then why in the event of a bad event is only the man under the spotlight, and not the deed as well? Sure, bringing the man under the microscope does give an insight, but it also happens that such a close examination narrows our perspective, and we lose sight of the bigger picture. Instead of nipping such problems in the bud, we are allowing them to bloom fully, and then paying the price in the distant future. We gravitate to the men who are flawed, either for self-aggrandizing or for vicarious pleasure, and neither is anything to be too proud of.

The Tejpals, Asarams et al are not just exceptions to any grand rule, they are exactly like us; just that they couldn't sate their voracious appetites. But that is no reason to focus on them so keenly; we would do better to focus on the bigger malaise afflicting us, which would be the wise thing.

No comments:

Post a Comment