Surely this has to be the topic which brings out all sorts of passions inside us. Irrespective of barriers. The levels of vehemence which are attained during such a discussion are just unbelievable. I guess that is the beauty about sports. There is a raw side to it, which espouses and invokes such deep emotions that we are caught in them.
While a similar debate can, and indeed does, happen for other professions as well, sports is a different ball game altogether. We can connect to it, and indeed we live vicariously through the legends and the greats who achieve such feats in their various arenas and stadia. This led to a (not too) narrow stream, namely of sports.
Time and again, each sport brings forth individuals (and teams) who literally transcend hitherto existing levels of excellence. Brazil 1970, Lin Dan, Usain Bolt et al are just a few examples off the top of my head. Each of these can claim the tag of the greatest. But what makes them so? Is it only numbers which can define that status?
Numbers are obviously the best point to start any such discussion. I guess that is the beauty of numbers in general, and statistics in particular. They certainly separate the best from the rest. After all, the also ran will not have numbers comparable to a winner, in an overwhelming majority of the cases. They tell a good portion of the story associated with each sports entity. Only a good portion, however. If only numbers were to be the deciding factor, there would be no debate at all. So it can be agreed that numbers alone are not enough.
To aid the numbers, it is important to note as to how those numbers were achieved, which is basically the setting in which the performances occurred, and the impact of the athlete (team).
So simple, isn't it?
Part of the reason why there is rarely any unanimity in such discussions is that there is no measurement for impact (statistically there may be, and that is a downside for me). Impact here may be on both the sport and the individual stating the case for a particular entity. And that, more than anything else, is the beauty of such debates. I may have been impacted by one player more than any other, and there is no way that can be broken down into numbers.
Time brings about many changes in the world. Sports is also affected. Rules change, and so do the conditions. Since the discussion is for the greatest of all time, it will come to a stage where there will be a comparison of entities from entirely different eras, arguably the most difficult thing to do. And in such debates, this also marks the point of no return. Ultimately, it becomes a comparison of the impacts of the respective entities which, as pointed out, will always remain subjective.
Impact takes on another dimension, when the debate is about the greatest player in a team sport (football, cricket). It is the impact of the player on the team. So, it's another subjective parameter, and is of no help whatsoever in arriving at an objective decision. But then again, such debates are for entertainment, not for arriving at a decision. Had the latter been the case, our ingenious human minds would have come up with a complicated formula to reach a decision.
Long live the debate, and may it forever be healthy and furious!
While a similar debate can, and indeed does, happen for other professions as well, sports is a different ball game altogether. We can connect to it, and indeed we live vicariously through the legends and the greats who achieve such feats in their various arenas and stadia. This led to a (not too) narrow stream, namely of sports.
Time and again, each sport brings forth individuals (and teams) who literally transcend hitherto existing levels of excellence. Brazil 1970, Lin Dan, Usain Bolt et al are just a few examples off the top of my head. Each of these can claim the tag of the greatest. But what makes them so? Is it only numbers which can define that status?
Numbers are obviously the best point to start any such discussion. I guess that is the beauty of numbers in general, and statistics in particular. They certainly separate the best from the rest. After all, the also ran will not have numbers comparable to a winner, in an overwhelming majority of the cases. They tell a good portion of the story associated with each sports entity. Only a good portion, however. If only numbers were to be the deciding factor, there would be no debate at all. So it can be agreed that numbers alone are not enough.
To aid the numbers, it is important to note as to how those numbers were achieved, which is basically the setting in which the performances occurred, and the impact of the athlete (team).
So simple, isn't it?
Part of the reason why there is rarely any unanimity in such discussions is that there is no measurement for impact (statistically there may be, and that is a downside for me). Impact here may be on both the sport and the individual stating the case for a particular entity. And that, more than anything else, is the beauty of such debates. I may have been impacted by one player more than any other, and there is no way that can be broken down into numbers.
Time brings about many changes in the world. Sports is also affected. Rules change, and so do the conditions. Since the discussion is for the greatest of all time, it will come to a stage where there will be a comparison of entities from entirely different eras, arguably the most difficult thing to do. And in such debates, this also marks the point of no return. Ultimately, it becomes a comparison of the impacts of the respective entities which, as pointed out, will always remain subjective.
Impact takes on another dimension, when the debate is about the greatest player in a team sport (football, cricket). It is the impact of the player on the team. So, it's another subjective parameter, and is of no help whatsoever in arriving at an objective decision. But then again, such debates are for entertainment, not for arriving at a decision. Had the latter been the case, our ingenious human minds would have come up with a complicated formula to reach a decision.
Long live the debate, and may it forever be healthy and furious!
No comments:
Post a Comment